Building and maintaining a successful commercial cleaning operation requires strategic decisions about how to structure your workforce. One option many contract cleaning businesses consider is using subcontractors. This approach can offer flexibility and potential cost savings, but it also comes with significant tradeoffs that deserve careful consideration. For a deeper dive into choosing between subcontractors vs full time employees, explore this detailed guide to help make the best decision for your business.
What Are Subcontractors in the Cleaning Industry?
In the commercial cleaning industry, subcontractors are independent professionals or small cleaning companies that work under contract with a larger cleaning operation. Unlike employees, subcontractors maintain their independence, typically using their own equipment, setting their own schedules, and managing their own tax obligations.
When you hire a subcontractor, you’re essentially outsourcing specific cleaning assignments or specialized services under your company’s brand. The subcontractor fulfills the work requirements according to the terms of your agreement, but they remain legally separate from your organization.
Before finalizing any subcontracting agreement, ensure subcontractors carry adequate liability insurance, possess required licenses, and fully comply with local labor laws and regulations. Neglecting these verifications could lead to increased liability and potential legal complications for your business.
This arrangement differs fundamentally from traditional employment relationships, where you would hire, train, and directly manage cleaning staff who work exclusively for your company. Understanding this distinction is critical, as it affects everything from legal requirements to quality control processes.
Pros of Using Subcontractors in Your Cleaning Business
Reduced Overhead Costs
One of the most compelling advantages of hiring a subcontractor is the potential for significant cost savings. When you work with subcontractors, you typically avoid expenses like employment taxes, benefits, workers’ compensation insurance, and unemployment insurance. You’re also not responsible for purchasing and maintaining equipment and supplies for these workers, as subcontractors generally provide their own.
For companies operating on thin margins, these savings can make a substantial difference to your bottom line, allowing you to be more competitive with your pricing while maintaining profitability.
Scalability During Demand Peaks
The cleaning industry often experiences fluctuations in demand. You might secure a large one-time project, need to cover seasonal increases in work, or face unexpected staff shortages at critical times. Subcontractors provide the flexibility to scale your workforce up or down quickly without the commitment of hiring permanent employees.
This elasticity in your workforce allows you to take on larger projects or special cleaning assignments that might otherwise be beyond your capacity, creating opportunities for business growth without the risk of overextending your resources.
Access to Specialized Expertise
Not every cleaning job requires the same skill set. Some clients may need specialized services like post-construction cleaning, medical facility sanitization, or carpet and upholstery restoration. Rather than training your staff in every possible specialty or turning away these profitable jobs, you can subcontract them to experts who already have the necessary skills, certifications, and equipment.
This approach allows you to expand your service offerings without significant investment in training or specialized equipment, making your operation more attractive to clients who need comprehensive cleaning solutions.
Easily Expand Your Service Area
Geographic expansion presents significant logistical challenges for cleaning operations. Sending your regular staff to distant locations means higher transportation costs, overtime pay, and potential scheduling complexities. By partnering with subcontractors who already work in those areas, you can serve clients in new locations without these additional costs and complications.
This strategy allows your company to grow its geographic footprint strategically, testing new markets before committing to a permanent presence there.
Lower Administrative Burden
Managing employees requires significant administrative work, including payroll processing, tax withholding, benefits administration, and compliance with various labor regulations. With subcontractors, much of this administrative burden disappears. However, managing independent contractors still requires efficient scheduling and task management, making robust cleaning scheduling software essential for streamlining processes and maintaining oversight. You simply pay their invoices according to your agreement, significantly reducing paperwork and administrative overhead.
For many contract cleaners, particularly smaller operations with limited administrative staff, this reduction in paperwork and regulatory compliance requirements can free up valuable time to focus on business development and client relationships.
Quick Workforce Onboarding
When you win a new contract or need to replace a team member quickly, the hiring process for employees can be time-consuming. From posting job listings and conducting interviews to completing background checks and orientation training, bringing on new employees often takes weeks.
Subcontractors, by contrast, can often be onboarded much more quickly. Since they’re already established in the industry with their own training and equipment, they can typically begin work shortly after agreeing to terms, allowing you to respond rapidly to new opportunities or unexpected staffing gaps.
Reducing the Risk of Long-Term Employee Costs
Hiring permanent employees represents a significant long-term commitment. If business slows down or you lose a major contract, you may face difficult decisions about retaining staff or potentially incurring costs related to layoffs. Subcontractors provide a buffer against these risks, as their contracts can be structured to align with your specific project timeframes or can include clauses for scaling back when necessary.
Take advantage of the value Janitorial Manager can bring to your cleaning operation to streamline your processes like never before. Learn more today with a discovery call and find out how features like QR codes, timekeeping, and workloading can make your operations more effective and easier to manage!
Cons of Using Subcontractors in Your Cleaning Business
Less Control Over Quality
Perhaps the most significant drawback of using subcontractors is the reduced direct control over cleaning quality. While employees work under your immediate supervision and follow your established protocols, subcontractors maintain greater independence in how they complete tasks. This can lead to inconsistencies in cleaning standards, particularly if the subcontractor doesn’t fully understand or align with your company’s quality expectations.
Mitigating quality control risks requires clearly documented standards within subcontractor agreements. Explicitly defining your brand values, cleaning standards, and operational procedures helps subcontractors align closely with your organization’s expectations, minimizing inconsistencies in service delivery
For companies whose reputation depends on consistent, high-quality service, this potential quality variance represents a substantial risk that needs careful management through clear agreements and regular quality checks.
Potential for Client Poaching
When you introduce a subcontractor to your clients, you’re creating a direct connection between them that could potentially bypass your company. Unethical subcontractors might attempt to cultivate relationships with your clients and eventually offer their services directly at lower rates, effectively stealing your business.
This risk is particularly acute in the cleaning industry, where ongoing client relationships are the lifeblood of successful operations. Protecting against this requires carefully crafted non-compete clauses in subcontractor agreements and vigilant management of client interactions.
Using detailed service-level agreements (SLAs) with subcontractors can significantly reduce ambiguity around expectations, responsibilities, and performance metrics. Clearly defined SLAs provide a contractual foundation for managing performance and addressing issues swiftly if they arise.
Higher Costs for Skilled Work
While subcontracting in your cleaning business can reduce costs for standard cleaning services, specialized work often comes at a premium. Subcontractors with niche expertise like biohazard cleanup, high-rise window cleaning, or specialized floor restoration typically charge higher rates than what you might pay an employee with similar skills.
These premium costs can significantly impact your profit margins if not carefully factored into your client pricing, potentially making certain specialized services less profitable when subcontracted.
Potential Penalties for Mislabeling Workers
One of the most serious risks in subcontracting relationships is worker misclassification. If you treat subcontractors too much like employees—providing extensive training, requiring them to follow specific schedules, or supplying equipment—tax authorities may determine they should be classified as employees. This misclassification can result in significant penalties, back taxes, and legal complications.
For companies navigating these classification rules requires careful attention to how subcontractor relationships are structured and managed, often necessitating legal guidance to ensure compliance with ever-evolving regulations.
Risk of Unreliability
When you hire employees, you have significant control over their schedules and can build redundancy into your staffing plans. With subcontractors, you’re dependent on their reliability and commitment to fulfilling their contractual obligations. If a subcontractor fails to show up or performs inadequately, you may have limited immediate recourse, potentially jeopardizing client relationships.
This reliability risk is particularly concerning for cleaning operations that service time-sensitive environments like healthcare facilities, event venues, or retail locations where cleaning must occur during specific windows.
Brand Consistency Challenges
Your cleaning operation’s brand encompasses more than just cleaning quality—it includes how your representatives interact with clients, the appearance and professionalism they project, and the consistency of service delivery. Subcontractors who work with multiple companies may not fully embrace or represent your specific brand values and culture, creating inconsistencies in how clients experience your services.
For companies focused on building a distinctive market position and reputation, these brand consistency challenges can undermine long-term brand development efforts and client loyalty.
When Should You Consider Using Subcontractors?
Given these pros and cons, when does it make sense to incorporate subcontractors into your cleaning operation? Consider subcontracting in these scenarios:
- During periods of rapid growth when you need to quickly expand capacity without the long-term commitment of hiring permanent staff
- For specialized services that are requested occasionally but don’t justify maintaining specialized staff and equipment
- When expanding into new geographic areas where you want to test market potential before establishing a permanent presence
- For large one-time projects that exceed your regular staffing capacity
- During seasonal demand spikes when temporarily increasing your workforce makes economic sense
The key is to be strategic about when and how you use subcontractors, leveraging their flexibility while mitigating the potential risks to quality and client relationships.
Best Practices for Managing Subcontractors Effectively
If you decide that subcontracting makes sense for your cleaning operation, implementing these best practices can help maximize the benefits while minimizing the risks:
- Create detailed subcontractor agreements that clearly outline expectations for quality, communication protocols, confidentiality requirements, and non-compete provisions.
- Develop a thorough vetting process for subcontractors, including background checks, reference verification, proof of insurance, and assessment of technical capabilities.
- Implement a comprehensive quality control system with regular inspections and client feedback mechanisms to ensure subcontractors maintain your standards.
- Establish clear communication channels and reporting requirements to maintain visibility into how work is being performed and address issues promptly.
- Build relationships with multiple subcontractors for each service area to ensure you have backup options if reliability issues arise.
- Consult with legal and tax professionals to ensure your subcontractor relationships are properly structured to avoid misclassification issues.
- Consider using technology to track subcontractor performance, schedule assignments, and document quality checks to maintain accountability.
By following these practices, you can create a subcontractor management system that supports your business goals while protecting your client relationships and brand reputation.
Subcontracting in your cleaning operation represents a strategic choice that comes with significant tradeoffs. By carefully weighing the pros and cons against your specific business needs and implementing robust management practices, you can leverage subcontractors as a valuable component of your workforce strategy without compromising the quality and consistency that clients expect.
Keep up with your vendors, customers, staff, schedules, and checklists. Learn more today with a discovery call and find out how to make your cleaning operation more efficient, cost-effective, and better for everyone!
